The Best 4 Slice Toasters Under $100 for 2022

In a perfect world, toast would come out of the toaster just the way we like it ten times out of ten. However, just like making the perfect eggs every morning, alongside the precision of the crispy bacon, toast is another part of the breakfast puzzle, which needs to be mastered to perfection so we can enjoy our first meal of the day every morning and start our day with a smile.

What Is The Best 4 Slice Toaster Under 100?

Cuisinart CPT-180 Metal Classic 4-Slice Toaster

With all we said and discussed so far, the Cuisinart CPT-180 is pretty much the best  4 slice toaster you can get on the market, penny for penny. Its exquisite design, polished clean look, stainless steel body are sure to last you a long time before you even consider another option. It is lightweight, easy to use, with plenty of different settings to choose from.

Cuisinart makes some of the best appliances and kitchenware and they stand by their products and design. Hopefully, by now you already have a good idea of what you are looking for and can confidently walk to the store to make an educated purchase and take your new four-slice toaster home.

Now imagine you have to do all of this but 4 different ways for every member of the family. At least when it comes to the toast 4 slice toasters are quite common now but come with many different options and, depending on our needs, there are certain ones that better than others.

The 5 Best 4 Slice Toasters Under $100:

We look at five of the best 4 slice toasters under $100 on the market today and see what they have to offer:

1. Cuisinart CPT-180 Metal Classic 4-Slice Toaster

Let’s cut to the chase. Stainless steel is the daddy of all when it comes to home appliances. The Cuisinart CPT-180 is probably the best Cuisinart toaster you can get for the price you pay. The retro clean design with a solid finish really catches the eye and gives out a feel for a solid product. There are six shade control settings on both sides varying from light shaded crispy to dark shades but never feel like you are getting coal out of the toaster.

There are multiple toasting functions: the standard toast to defrost and reheat options as well as a cancel button to immediately eject the toast when you feel it is just right. The slots of the toaster are extra wide at an inch and a half to accommodate a variety of toasty options from sliced bread to frozen pancakes as well as toaster pastries.

There is a specific bagel option for each side of the double slots so you can get your morning bagel crisp to perfection. And if you are tired of toasters which don’t pop the bread all the way up, then look no further than Cuisinart.

Their Hi-Lift levers allow you to lift the lever upwards so you can easily get your slice out of the unit. The defrost function uses the same dials like the toast function and each setting allows for faster and better defrost of different items from the thinner frozen pancakes at the lowest setting to the thicker frozen bagels at the highest.

Cuisinart’s CPT-180 4 slice toaster is a great purchase at a great price and you will not regret your decision if you opt for it.

2. BLACK+DECKER 4-Slice Toaster

With Black and Decker’s Extra Wide 4 slice toaster, you will really be able to feel the dark side of the Force and burn your toast to the ground if you wish. The design sure looks like it came out of an Imperial Destroyer in Star Wars, or straight out of Darth Vader’s room, and it is sure to turn a few fan heads.

There are seven toast shade settings to match everyone’s tastes and are conveniently numbered on the selector nobs. Once again, we have the option to defrost and cancel, however, this toaster doesn’t have the reheat option Cuisinart’s has. The extra-wide slots are again present to help accommodate any bread, thin and wide, as well as a bagel with a designated button alongside the others.

Quite a convenient feature is the addition of slide-out trays under both dual slots, so you can keep your countertops clean and fresh by easily removing the crumbs before they burn up and start smelling nasty.

This toaster also has the extra lift feature so you can get to your toast safely if it has become stuck in the slot. Overall, this is a very reasonable option, which also looks good with its black aluminum finish and will serve all your basic breakfast needs and help you start your day the right way.

3. Hamilton Beach Classic Chrome 4 Slice Toaster

The Hamilton Beach Classic Chrome toaster is another nice stainless steel product with a variety of functions and quite a few features, which make it a great small appliance for any kitchen. Design-wise it isn’t as sleek looking as the Cuisinart one but can do just as many things to make your toast as precise as you want it. There are eight settings on the toast shade dial with three picture indicators letting you know how dark you want your toast.

There is a reheat defrost an on/cancel button as well as a bagel button like the previous entries, because of the wide trays this toaster comes with. With this setting, the bagel, English muffin, or bun you decide to place in the tray would only toast on one side of the cut for that perfect experience.

There are also convenient crumb trays nicely placed and labeled under each dual side, so you don’t make a mess of your counters in the kitchen or start burning more than you want.

Speaking of burns, you wouldn’t have to worry about burning yourself by accidentally touching the exterior of the toaster as it is cool to the touch to prevent any mishaps. The boost feature on the handles also allows for easy access to stuck toast or if any slice didn’t pop out all the way. Another extra safety feature is the auto shut off so you wouldn’t set off any fire alarms by forgetting your toast in the toaster.

Finally, Hamilton beach includes even a cord wrap for easier storage if you don’t want to or don’t have the counter space to have it out all the time. This is a decent 4 slice toaster made by one of the best-known companies and is sure to be a great addition to any household.

4. Oster Long Slot Stainless Steel 4-Slice Toaster

Here we have another bestseller on the market, made for the lovers of longer bread and bigger bagels. Sleek stainless steel design, mint fresh look with nothing looking out of place, this is one appliance anyone would love to place on any kitchen countertop.

There are seven different shading settings on the dial to fine-tune the bread shade of every slice of toast. The toaster also features the bagel warm and defrost option buttons right next to the dial and a cancel button on the other side.

One feature this product has that no other on the list so far are the auto-adjusting bread guides which make sure your toast is the exact same shade throughout and not missing certain areas or over burning others. The long trays can be both convenient and a letdown for some.

On one hand, you can put weirder slices of bread and different shapes or just place four regular slices. On the other hand, however, since there are only two trays on this four-slice toaster you don’t have the option of the other double dual tray toasters where you can have separate settings for every side. The removable crumb tray is also dishwasher-safe, so cleaning is easy and quick without too much hassle.

Another downside of this being longer than wider is the lack of storage for the power cord so if you want to be more compact you would have to look for a different option. This is overall another solid pick from a fantastic company.

The price tag is high but it brings a lot to the table with the polished stainless steel design, fresh look as well as the auto-adjusting guides in the tray this is a great choice for people who love to experiment with a variety of shapes of bread.

5. KitchenAid Kmt4115cu 4-Slice Toaster with Manual High-Lift Lever

Finally, we have the KitchenAid 4 – slice toaster with a manual high-lift lever. Another stainless steel toaster, which looks stylish and clean, durable and long-lasting like other modern toasters. The four wide trays allow for many options to choose from for your next breakfast or brunch toast – bagels, English muffins, thicker hand-sliced pieces of bread can all fit the trays and get to the desired shade.

There are five settings on the shade dial from light to dark and crispy, whichever way you like yours.  The dual controls let you toast two slices independently from the other two.

Unfortunately, this model only comes with a bagel program button, so defrosting waffles and pancakes is not something you would be able to do. There is, however, a cancel function to instantly pop the tray up and with the manual high-lift levers even the smallest slices of bread would be within your reach and easily accessible.

The crumb tray is easily removable, but it can only be hand-washed, which is inconvenient but not the end of the world. There is storage for the power cord under the base which makes it easier to store away the toaster, but you should really consider keeping it in one place most of the time because it is on the heavier side compared to other 4 slice toasters.

Rocking a higher than most price tag, what the KitchenAid 4 slice toaster lacks in functionality, makes up for in design and durability. It is certainly up there with the other high-end options so don’t discard it when you consider your options.

What to look for when buying a 4 slice toaster

In this top five list, we covered various options on the market today. There are many more on the market and it is important to know what is key and what to neglect when you look through the features and details of the four-slice toasters you are looking through. This following buyers’ guide will help you better understand which features are important and hopefully by the time you finish this article you will be confident when purchasing your next toaster.

The Size

Since we are talking about four-slice toasters and not two-slice or toaster ovens, you already have a general idea of how big your toaster is going to be. However, this is not the only size to consider. Aside from figuring out if you have enough countertop space where you can put your four-slice toaster, also think about the size of the toaster slots.

If you would want to make more than regular toast, but also other products like bagels or waffles or pancakes or muffins, make sure the slots are wide enough to accommodate a variety of choices.

The Price

Pop-up toasters vary in price. Make sure you know what you are paying for. The cheaper models are usually ones who would serve your needs just fine but are made of cheaper materials and wouldn’t last as long. Furthermore, they wouldn’t have extra functions like the pricier options.

The higher priced toasters are usually made of stainless steel and are cold to the touch on the outside to provide even better safety from accidental burns. These models can easily last you a lifetime or until you decide you want something new.

The settings

Speaking of extra functions, also consider what you will be using the toaster for. Will you be making just regular toast every morning? Will you want to have a bagel occasionally?

Maybe reheat something, which went cold? Or maybe just defrost a pancake or a waffle and have a nice weekend breakfast with some goodies you have handy in the freezer? These are all functions toasters that are more expensive have and can perfectly perform.

Cleaning

Lastly, you should look into how easy it would be to clean and maintain your toaster. Having a nice pull-out crumb tray which is dishwasher safe is one way to make your life easier.

You won’t have burnt crumbs to constantly rattle over the trash or even worse if there is no tray at all you will be stuck cleaning crumbs off your countertop every morning or afternoon. If you aren’t this picky, a tray that can only be washed by hand is still a much better option than having no tray at all.